In season

Pumpkin Spice

$30 9 inch pie

You may think you don’t like pumpkin pie, but give this a try! Sweeter then traditional pumpkin pie with our fudge texture and yummy spice flavor of cinnamon, ginger and nutmeg.

Our packaging ships our pies safely nation wide! We recommend you store our pies in the freezer until you are ready to cut and serve.

9-inch diameter, 32 ounces, 12 - 16 servings

Consider buying two pies. Shipping costs the same!

9 inch diameter · 32 ounces · 12 to 16 servings

Pre-orders open October 1

Pre-orders open October 1 to begin shipping November 1, and every pie arrives in time for your special occasion.

Shipped nationwide Keeps a year frozen Baked for the season

How it arrives

Our packaging ships our pies safely nationwide.

Storing and serving

We recommend you store our pies in the freezer until you are ready to cut and serve. Stored properly in the freezer, a pie keeps for up to a year.

Size and servings

Nine inch diameter, thirty two ounces, twelve to sixteen servings. Two pies ship for the same cost as one, so it is worth a second if you are feeding a crowd.

Kind words

What people are saying

“

★★★★★

I live in San Diego and have ordered pies from Stacey several times. Even shipping to San Diego they arrive in perfect, absolutely delicious shape. We served the Maple Pecan at Thanksgiving and it disappeared instantly.

E Edward T.
Yelp review

“

★★★★★

We had a large gathering and many people brought pies from fancy local bakers. We had a pie contest and The Fudge Pie Co won, by far. A Miami gem.

K Kaylee K.
Yelp review

“

★★★★★

The most unique, out of this world, deliciously tasting pies I have ever had. If you are a chocolate or fudge lover you have found your paradise with these pies.

J John S.
Google review

Also on the board